You Won’t Believe This Superman Scene Was Done 33 Years Earlier!

by

Reflecting on it now, I’m astonished that a key scene from a significant Superman film, known as “Man of Steel,” was strikingly similar to one that occurred 33 years prior in another DC movie featuring the same hero. Over the years, Superman’s cinematic journey has been varied, with its share of high points and lows. Nevertheless, we have a rich collection of classic Superman movies to appreciate, and these variations in portrayal of the character only serve to enrich our experience – a trend that I hope will continue in future DCU Superman films.

In differentiating these Kryptonian superheroes, each becomes unique, yet it’s intriguing to notice similarities that surface across various Superman films and narratives. This is particularly captivating when these common elements connect two contrasting big-screen adaptations of the legendary DC character. A notable instance of this can be seen in the significant similarities between a key scene in “Man of Steel” and an older Superman film, which featured its unique interpretation of that scene well before the DCEU timeline.

Man Of Steel’s Broadcast Scene Is A Crucial Part Of Its Story

General Zod’s Broadcast Brings Superman To Him

The main storyline of Man of Steel unfolds when General Zod announces over global broadcasts that he’s seeking a Kryptonian residing on Earth. Unbeknownst to him, this Kryptonian is Clark Kent. If the Kryptonian does not surrender, Zod vows to destroy Earth. Although Zod ultimately aims to transform Earth anyway, his threat proves compelling, leading Superman to eventually surrender himself to save others from harm.

As a die-hard movie enthusiast, I can’t help but marvel at how that particular scene stands out, even after all these decades. It’s fascinating to see the narrative unfold, displaying the global dissemination of Zod’s orders, translated into various languages to ensure every corner of Earth understood his commands. This created a sense of dread and anticipation for what might happen if this enigmatic other Kryptonian refused to comply with his demands. Remarkably, this scene echoes a pivotal moment from Superman 2, nearly thirty years its junior, making the parallel all the more intriguing given the divergent paths these films’ stories take elsewhere.

Superman 2 Pulled Off Almost The Exact Same Scene Decades Earlier

General Zod Calls Superman To Him With A Broadcast In Superman II As Well

In the movie “Superman II”, General Zod serves as the main antagonist. Unlike the original plot, this version explores different paths, initially focusing on Lois Lane’s quest to uncover Superman’s true identity and his momentary desire to lead a normal life by giving up his powers. However, this phase is short-lived, lasting only a few minutes, as Clark soon realizes that while he was enjoying time with Lois, General Zod had been seizing control of Earth. The President of the United States even makes a public announcement acknowledging submission to General Zod.

In a different scenario, when the President appeals to Superman for aid via broadcast, General Zod instead hijacks the message, summoning Superman and provoking him into a confrontation. This scene in ‘Superman II’ and ‘Man of Steel’ share similarities, as they both portray Zod as an escalating menace, making his threat seem more dire than initially perceived, and setting up the climactic battles that follow in each film.

In both films, Clark’s surroundings might not be exactly the same, but they share similarities. In “Man of Steel,” he watches the broadcast at his mother’s rural farmhouse, while in “Superman II,” he catches it at a secluded diner. This suggests that Clark had ample opportunities to avoid confronting Zod, yet he chose to face him, making his decision all the more significant. It underscores Superman’s dedication to protecting others and doing what is right, even if it comes at a personal cost.

Why The Man Of Steel & Superman 2 Scenes Are So Similar

The Two Versions Of Superman Have Some Core Similarities

In simpler terms, the portrayals of Superman in “Man of Steel” and “Superman II” differ significantly. Christopher Reeve’s Superman is a more cheerful and jovial character, fitting the classic era of Superman when the movies were released. On the other hand, Henry Cavill’s Superman has a darker, more brooding personality, which sets him apart from the lighter tone of the earlier movie version. This isn’t completely unprecedented in Superman comics or stories, but it does create a contrast with the previous cinematic portrayal.

Although they have distinct characteristics, the fundamental essence of these two Superman adaptations remains strikingly similar. Both characters embody a strong sense of justice and unwavering commitment to doing what’s right. Consequently, it is only fitting that the films pit them against General Zod as their greatest adversary, given his formidable power and ability to test Clark Kent’s resolve to defend Earth, the world he calls home, and its inhabitants.

In addition, this similarity between the two films in depicting Superman being called upon to confront General Zod through a broadcast serves multiple purposes. It not only provides a logical means for introducing the villain and the protagonist, but also offers an opportunity for Clark Kent to ponder whether he’s prepared to risk his life to face Zod. This internal struggle makes his eventual decision to engage seem more heroic. Furthermore, the mirroring of these scenes across three decades suggests their effectiveness, as they work effectively in both “Man of Steel” and “Superman II.

2025-06-20 03:08